Traverse City Record-Eagle

Other Views

June 15, 2013

Another View: Shield law only masks real flaw

When it chose to secretly seize phone records and e-mails from more than a hundred journalists, the Justice Department was behaving in the way of some tinpot dictatorship.

Liberals and conservatives alike condemned Justice’s fishing expedition, and Congress is hurrying to pass a media shield law similar to one that stalled a few years ago.

The backlash also could, and probably should, cost Attorney General Eric Holder his job. If this were just another poor decision on his part, it might be rationalized, but the attorney general comes across as an indifferent guardian of the Bill of Rights. That is intolerable.

In a democracy, basic rights sometimes clash. This is inevitable. What happens, for instance, when a criminal suspect’s Fifth Amendment right to confront a witness conflicts with a reporter’s First Amendment right to protect a source?

What happens is a balancing test. Typically, a judge would compel the reporter to divulge the source only after every reasonable, alternative way of getting the information had failed.

In other words, the court would respect and protect both rights as vigorously as possible. It would make the tough choice only as a last resort. This is what the Justice Department failed to do when it spied on Associated Press and Fox News reporters. It went fishing with a net instead of a hook.

Michigan and 48 other states (Wyoming is the outlier) enshrine a balancing test via shield laws. Judges, lawyers, detectives and others in the legal system cannot snap their fingers and force reporters to become agents of the state.

There is no federal shield law. The 2007 Free Flow of Information Act passed a Democrat-led House, but a GOP-organized filibuster killed it in the Senate.

Only one Democrat - Harry Reid of Nevada — joined the Bush administration in opposing the legislation. Four Democratic senators, including Barack Obama of Illinois, abstained.

Text Only

Twitter Updates
Follow us on twitter
Associated Press Video
Baby Sloths Squeak for Their Cuddle Partners in Adorable Video Miley Cyrus Hospitalized After Severe Reaction To Medicine Raw: Ferry Sinks Off South Korean Coast Toddler climbs into vending machine 8-year-old Boy Gets His Wish: Fly Like Iron Man Much-Anticipated 'Gone Girl' Trailer Finally Debuts! (VIDEO) Dog and Toddler Wear Matching Outfits in Adorable Photo Series VP Biden: "World witnesses ordinary citizens doing extraordinary things" It's Official! Michael Strahan Joins "GMA" Blood Moon Time-lapse Actress Lake Bell Goes Topless The Five Weirdest Local Taxes in America Applicants Vying for 'World's Toughest Job' Get Heartwarming Surprise Awkward: Crist catches Lt. Gov. insulting him on camera NASA Showcases Lunar Eclipse US Airways Tweets Graphic Photo of Nude Woman Behind the scenes of the Marathon anniversary photo shoot American Airlines Responds After Girl Tweets Alleged Terror Threat 'Joke' Charlie White's "Dancing" Mistake Olympic Great & Baltimore Native Michael Phelps Ends Retirement; Eyes Rio