Traverse City Record-Eagle


June 6, 2013

Editorial: DNA ruling opens door to unanticipated results

A U.S. Supreme Court decision that clears the way for police to take a DNA swab from anyone they arrest for a serious crime is a collision between 21st Century technology and 18th Century ideals. And in this case, the 21st Century won.

Ruling in a Maryland case, the court split 5-4 to allow DNA samples to be taken from suspects. Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority, said analyzing an arrestee’s “DNA is, like fingerprinting and photographing, a legitimate police booking procedure ...”

That may be true, but it ignores the fact that a DNA analysis is also a search and, as a Maryland court had earlier ruled, it violates the assumption that a suspect has “a (sufficient expectation) of privacy against warrantless, suspicionless searches” under the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution.

Justice Antonin Scalia, one of the court’s most conservative members, predicted the limitation to “serious” crimes would not last. “Make no mistake about it,” he said “... your DNA can be taken and entered into a national database if you are ever arrested, rightly or wrongly, and for whatever reason.”

“This will solve some extra crimes, to be sure,” he wrote. “But so would taking your DNA when you fly on an airplane — surely the (Transportation Security Administration) must know the ‘identity’ of the flying public. For that matter, so would taking your children’s DNA when they start public school.”

This is the classic slippery slope — consequences the Founding Fathers likely never imagined when they wrote the Fourth Amendment to protect individuals from overzealous, unfair prosecution.

Who is to say how DNA information, once in the hands of the government, will be used?

Text Only

Opinion Poll
AP Video
Raw: Families Travel to Taiwan Plane Crash Site Arizona Execution Takes Almost Two Hours Gen. Odierno Discusses Ukraine, NATO at Forum Gaza Fighting Rages Amid Cease-Fire Efforts Mint Gives JFK Coin a Face-lift Creative Makeovers for Ugly Cellphone Towers Ariz. Inmate Dies 2 Hours After Execution Began Crash Kills Teen Pilot Seeking World Record LeBron James Sends Apology Treat to Neighbors Raw: Funeral for Man Who Died in NYPD Custody Migrants Back in Honduras After US Deports Israeli American Reservist Torn Over Return Raw: ISS Cargo Ship Launches in Kazakhstan Six Indicted in StubHub Hacking Scheme Former NTSB Official: FAA Ban 'prudent' EPA Gets Hip With Kardashian Tweet Bodies of MH17 Victims Arrive in the Netherlands Biden Decries Voting Restrictions in NAACP Talk Broncos Owner Steps Down Due to Alzheimer's US, UN Push Shuttle Diplomacy in Mideast