Michigan truth squad analysis: "Companies like Mine"
Who: Stabenow for Senate
What: TV and Web ad
Truth Squad call: No foul
Questionable statement: "At American Expedition Vehicles we have over 500 employees and their jobs are in jeopardy due to counterfeit parts coming out of China."
American Expedition Vehicles is a Livonia-based company that builds custom vehicles and products for the Jeep aftermarket. The company says it has been a victim of low-quality knockoffs from a variety of countries, including China, Germany and Malaysia.
"Counterfeit products harm our customers and our company. Due to quality concerns, many of the counterfeits we have found entering the market can impact vehicle performance and make them potentially dangerous to operate," the company says on its website.
It has posted photos of counterfeit products, including information about a Chinese counterfeit front bumper. Michigan has lost hundreds of thousands of manufacturing jobs over the past decade, and both business leaders and many members of Congress on both sides of the aisle say counterfeit parts and unfair trade practices contribute to the problem.
Questionable statement: "That's why Debbie Stabenow wrote the bill cracking down on unfair Chinese trade violations and currency manipulation that hurt American businesses." When the narrator asserts that Stabenow "wrote the bill," he would more accurately say she "wrote a version of a bill." The screen cites S1830 of 2011 (The Protect American Innovation Act) and S1027 of 2009 (The Currency Reform for Fair Trade Act), both sponsored by Stabenow.
A bipartisan version of the currency reform law passed the Senate, but not the House. The Protect American Innovation Act hasn't been considered, although Senate committee chairman Sen. Max Baucus said he would take it up later this year after Stabenow agreed not to try to attach the measure to other legislation.
Questionable statement: "Senator Stabenow understands the threat of counterfeit products coming out of China and she is working with companies like mine all over Michigan saving manufacturing jobs."
Stabenow has worked a great deal on legislation to combat unfair trade practices, including counterfeiting and currency manipulation. In 2006, she called for the creation of an international trade prosecutor's office. She has proposed an American Competitiveness Plan that targets currency manipulation, creates a trade enforcement office to hold countries accountable for violating trade laws and strengthens penalties for counterfeiting and technology theft.
When she introduced her television ad in Grand Rapids, she had the backing of a Republican businessman, Alexander Dodds' CEO Mark Chappell, who says his company has been hurt by Chinese counterfeiting and he is supporting her because of her efforts to fight counterfeiting.
There is disagreement over whether Stabenow's approach would be effective. For instance, on the issue of currency sanctions, Derek Scissors, a research fellow in Asia Economic Policy at the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, contends the jobs would instead shift to other low-wage countries such as Bangladesh or Vietnam, rather than come back to the U.S.
Overall impression: In launching her first television ad of her re-election campaign against Republican Pete Hoekstra, Stabenow casts herself as a fighter for Michigan businesses and workers. After a decade of struggle, Michigan's recovery is under way, and Stabenow believes fair trade practices will serve to strengthen the economy. It's largely a noncontroversial ad because no one will support counterfeiting.
Foul or no foul: No foul.
Michigan truth squad analysis: "Companies like Mine"
Letters to the Editor: 12/04/2013
Litter is not OK; U.N. has an agenda.Continued ...
Another View: Dislike freeloaders? Change state law
No one likes a freeloader. Count Michigan teachers among that number.Continued ...
Another View: Bumpy roads surely ahead for Mich.
No one should have been surprised when Gov. Rick Snyder’s plan to get $1.2 billion in new road funds fell flat in the Legislature in 2013.Continued ...
Editorial: Big Rock’s nuke waste site got a pass
The issue: Critics assail Canadian nuke waste plan. Our view: Little has been said about how Big Rock’s waste is stored.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 12/03/2013
Competition beneficial; Bill the owner.Continued ...
Another View: We share blame with Washington
‘We the people’ must share the blame for the nation’s political mess.Continued ...
- Monday, December 2, 2013
Cheers & Jeers: 12/02/2013
To Solar Up North Alliance program, a partnership between Cherryland Electric Cooperative and Traverse City Light and Power which allows customers to lease a solar panel for $470 with a $75 rebate, for winning the “Exemplary Project” award from the Great Lakes Renewable Energy Association.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 12/02/2013
Keeping downtown vibrant; Prevention is best.Continued ...
- Sunday, December 1, 2013
Editorial: TBAISD can't defend bulging fund balance
To hear Traverse Bay Area Intermediate School District superintendent Mike Hill tell it, his board members understand the plight of cash-strapped area school districts that want the ISD to share some of its wealth, but worry that the ISD has its own financial house to look after first.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 12/01/2013
Sky isn’t falling; Plan could backfire.Continued ...
Jack Lessenberry: Auto bailout massive success
By the time the ball comes down in Times Square on New Year’s Eve, a big change will have taken place at General Motors.Continued ...
George Weeks: Wages, Obamacare loom in campaigns
Wages are an escalating economic and political issue across the country.|Wages are an escalating economic and political issue across the country. Walmart, the nation’s largest retailer, has had worker protests on the issue. Democratic politicians are beating the drums for increases in the minimum wage. In Michigan, MarkContinued ...
- Saturday, November 30, 2013
Did Obama team announce Iran deal to distract?
By PolitiFact.com Within hours of the United States announcing an initial nuclear deal with Iran on Nov. 23, 2013, a few critics of President Barack Obama began to muse publicly about whether the announcement was timed to distract the American publicContinued ...
Letters to the Editor: 11/30/2013
Best salute possible; Global action needed.Continued ...
- Friday, November 29, 2013
Letters to the Editor: 11/29/2013
We can do both; The taxpayer paysContinued ...
Another View: Compromise on charitable gambling
Michigan's gaming regulators and a large number of Michigan charities are squared off over proposed changes in the rules that govern gambling events that provide funds for hundreds of community groups across the state. Compromise is in order. MembersContinued ...
Editorial: Address snow on downtown sidewalks
When you live in northern Lower Michigan, snow is part of the deal.Continued ...
- Thursday, November 28, 2013
Editorial: FDR's words of 1941 just as true today
On Jan. 6, 1941, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt spoke about the role of the United States in a troubled world and about “four freedoms” that form the foundation of the democracy we know as the United States.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 11/28/2013
Judged by treatment; Wise up.Continued ...
Forum: Honoring loved ones during holidays
The holidays are approaching fast. As beautiful and as spiritual the holidays can be, when someone you love has died it can be one of the most difficult times of the year.Continued ...
Phil Power: Thanksgiving reflection time
Thanksgiving week is a time to remember, to reflect, to give thanks.Continued ...
- Wednesday, November 27, 2013
Editorial: Pension proposal deserves no-strings vote
The issue: Some GT Commissioners say their votes can be had on pension plan. Our view: This issue is too important to be decided by horse trading.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 11/27/2013
Consider another option; Pay close attention.Continued ...
Forum: Structuring collaborative partnerships
In this world of constant change, requirements for dealing with the contradictions that arise from today’s environment should encourage leadership in the public sector to think differently when structuring collaborative partnerships.Continued ...
- Tuesday, November 26, 2013
Editorial: Student loan debt weighs on best, brightest
The issue: Student loan debt tops $1.2 trillion. Our view: It’s a broken system that must be changed.Continued ...
- Letters to the Editor: 12/04/2013