Who: Michigan Energy, Michigan Jobs — Pro-Proposal 3 group
Featured Truth Squad Material: TV ads
Truth Squad call: Technical foul
Michigan Energy Michigan Jobs (MEMJ) is a ballot proposal committee supporting Proposal 3, a measure to require utilities to obtain 25 percent of Michigan's electric needs from renewable sources by 2025 (with some caveats). MEMJ is a coalition of environmental, alternative energy, union and business interests.
In the latest reporting period ending July 20, the group raised $2,247,277, according to state campaign finance records. Of that amount, $1,772,000 came from clean-energy advocacy organizations in San Francisco and New York. Its largest in-state contribution was $450,000 from the Michigan League of Conservation Voters.
"Michigan spends billions importing coal from other states and oil from the Middle East. (Text on screen: '1.7 Billion to other states. Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration Website.'")
This state report says Michigan spent $1.39 billion to buy coal to produce electricity. And all of the coal was imported.
Michigan imports 97 percent of its petroleum needs.
The state is expected to use 4.12 million gallons of gasoline in 2012.
Largest single source of U.S. petroleum imports is Canada; Persian Gulf nations constitute the second-largest source.
In 2011, the United States spent $327 billion on net oil imports, says the Congressional Research Service.
"That's right, 60 percent of Michigan's electricity comes from imported coal. (Text on screen: 60% OF ELECTRICITY FROM IMPORTED COAL)."
This Energy Information Administration analysis says three-fifths of the state's electric generation stems from coal. As noted above, a state report says all Michigan's coal is imported.
"It will create 94,000 jobs Michigan jobs and spark new businesses (Text on screen: create 94,000 jobs Michigan jobs. Source: Jobs and investment impact study done by MSU, 8/10/12; www.mienergymijobs.com/economicimpact)."
The study can be found on the site of the Michigan Environmental Council. The MEC is a supporter of Prop 3 and a member of MEMJ. The study notes that its work was "supported by a contract" between MSU and MEC. And an MEC spokesman confirmed that the group paid for the study.
The MEMJ page says 74,000 jobs would come from work toward the renewable standard. Another 20,000 would come from a 50 percent market capture of the manufacturing, for a total of 94,000.
However, that's not exactly what the study says. The summary notes:
"The $10.3 billion investment in renewable energy in Michigan that would be required by the proposed 25 percent by 2025 policy could create 74,495 job years (emphasis added) in Michigan, which is divided into 31,513 construction jobs years and 42,982 operations and maintenance job years. "¦ Additionally, there is potential to capture manufacturing job creation; however, the magnitude of that gain is dependent on the success of Michigan manufacturers' ability to capture market share in the renewable energy market."
A "job year" is a technical term, defined in this report as "Full employment for one person for 2,080 hours in a 12-month span."
As the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, a Midland-based free market think tank, cheekily noted: "That is, a person newly hired by a wind company and who works 25 years would count as 25 job years, though it is still just one job."
MEMJ counters that "job years is an academic term that is always translated as jobs." The group pointed to a Detroit News story from Sept. 5 about jobs created by natural gas drilling, which MEMJ says is based on a report that uses the same terminology.
But not every economist you speak to will agree with the terms' flexibility.
"There are 8,000 parts in a wind turbine and all of them can be made in Michigan."
A study by the Center on Globalization, Governance and Competitiveness at Duke University says a wind turbine has an estimated 8,000 parts.
The state's Michigan Economic Development Corp. says, "Michigan's industrial base, tuned to supporting the needs of the automotive industry, has all the expertise and capacity to handle the advanced precision manufacturing needs of the wind energy industry. In fact, federal studies rank Michigan among the top four states in industrial capacity to develop and manufacture wind energy systems."
"In West Michigan they make the blades."
Holland-based Energetx makes wind turbine blades.
"Astraeus wind manufacturing in mid-Michigan manufactures hubs."
Astraeus Wind in Eaton Rapids (southwest of Lansing) makes hubs.
"Danotek in Southeast Michigan makes high-tech generators that create clean energy and jobs."
Canton-based Danotek makes "high performance permanent magnets." Those parts are key to modern wind turbines.
The ad is better on describing Michigan's current electric generation situation than it is in describing the employment prospects if Proposal 3 is enacted. Michigan has seen considerable activity in the manufacture of, and siting of, wind turbines.
Truth squad call:
Technical foul, which Michigan Truth Squad defines as "A statement that implies something that isn't quite true and deserves additional explanation, or that is entirely false." A typical viewer is likely to think of a "job" being a "job" — something that will last, not something that ends in a year. Equating the word "job" with the economist term of "job year" certainly "deserves additional explanation."
Who: Michigan Energy, Michigan Jobs — Pro-Proposal 3 group
Letters to the Editor: 04/23/2014
Save the bats.Continued ...
Another View: State officials cease efforts to stop advance of ash borer
Kentucky’s war against the tiny emerald ash borer, responsible for already killing more than 25 million ash trees in the eastern United States has ended in surrender - by state officials, not the tiny insect.Continued ...
Another View: Pondering the jail problem
Our compliments to Vigo County Councilman Mark D. Bird for taking the time and investing the thought and energy into writing his detailed letter to the editor on the topic of the county’s jail, published in this newspaper April 13.Continued ...
Editorial: Eighth Street won't work until key issues resolved
Traverse City Commissioner Tim Werner was probably right. Unfortunately. During a recent walking tour of Eighth Street from Union to Woodmere, Werner jokingly objected to characterizing the argument about whether Eighth should be reduced from four to three lanes as the “never-ending debate.”Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 04/22/2014
Democracy for sale?; Are groups legitimate?Continued ...
Another View: Teachers contract should not be reopened
The mere talk of reopening a labor contract midway through its term borders on treason in this once union-strong town.Continued ...
- Monday, April 21, 2014
To Matthew Failor, 12, a seventh-grade student at Traverse City East Middle School, and William Kalajian, 13, an eighth-grade student at St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Middle School, who finished second and 10th respectively in the Michigan National Geographic Bee at Western Michigan University in Kalamazoo.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 04/21/2014
Check the logs; On a slippery slope.Continued ...
- Sunday, April 20, 2014
Editorial: To hear NMC tell it, public doesn't care
To hear some members of the Northwestern Michigan College Board of Trustees tell it, the public — that’s you — has virtually no interest in the board’s business and even less in having board meetings aired on public access television or videotaped as a permanent record.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 04/20/2014
Rarely a choice; Enjoy the ride.Continued ...
Forum: Time for revenue-neutral carbon tax
The U.S. Department of Defense, NASA, the American Medical Association, General Motors, the Catholic Church, Snowsports Industries America. What do they have in common? They all see climate change as a serious risk.Continued ...
Jack Lessenberry: Was Will Rogers right?
Ninety years ago, Will Rogers made audiences laugh by saying, “America has the best politicians money can buy.”Continued ...
George Weeks: Snyder touts statewide recycling plan
In 1976, Michigan voters wisely approved a ten-cent beverage bottle and can deposit plan that was applauded by environmentalists and became popular with consumers who recognized that their efforts to recycle with minor inconvenience have helped clear the countryside of clutter.Continued ...
- Saturday, April 19, 2014
Another View: Law can't regulate political content
"It's easy to tell when a politician is lying: Their lips move." That's a quote from the 1980s science fiction television series "Max Headroom." And while we may not share that cynicism in its entirety, it's hardly a secret that citizens need to treContinued ...
Fact Check: Peters says Koch brothers oppose Paycheck Fairness Act
Criticizing the Koch brothers and hitting Republicans for opposing the Paycheck Fairness Act are two key tenets of the Democratic midterm playbook. So when we found the Democrat in Michigan's open Senate race combining those attacks against his RepubContinued ...
Fact Check: Rand Paul's supply-side distortion
Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul claimed that 20 million jobs were created after President Ronald Reagan's dramatic tax cuts in the 1980s, and that this was the "last time" such job growth took place. Paul is wrong on both counts. The fact is that the economyContinued ...
- Friday, April 18, 2014
Warming study merits some skepticism
Those who support the theory of anthropogenic global warming, the idea that human activity is the major factor contributing to a precipitous rise in worldwide temperature averages, correctly argue that weather is not climate. Thus, whenever a big snoContinued ...
Defusing Ukraine's threat to peace in Europe
The announcement of an agreement at four-party talks on Ukraine Thursday is a major step toward defusing the crisis. This first step may pull us back from what has been called "the worst threat to peace in Europe since the Cold War." Russia promisedContinued ...
Finding a way to erase race card
WASHINGTON -- One approaches the race fray with trepidation, but here we go, tippy-toe. The race cards have been flying so fast and furious lately, one can hardly tell the kings from the queens. Leading the weird lately has been Democratic Alabama stContinued ...
No Headline Provided
Defusing Ukraine By Jack Segal The announcement of an agreement at four-party talks on Ukraine Thursday is a major step toward defusing the crisis. This first step may pull us back from what has been called "the worst threat to peace in Europe sinceContinued ...
- Thursday, April 17, 2014
Editorial: Surgery Center's business model a template for future
Imagine an additional 10,000 patients per year cycling through Munson Medical Center’s main campus. And not just people there to get a broken arm looked at, but surgery patients.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 04/17/2014
Let viewers decide; Serfs in America.Continued ...
Another View: Fracking 'earthquake' demands action
Confirmation by Ohio officials that fracking caused several low-level earthquakes near the Lawrence County border warrants attention.Continued ...
- Wednesday, April 16, 2014
Letters to the Editor: 04/16/2014
Willful ignorance?; Do the people matter?Continued ...
Another View: Don’t abandon bigger push to fix state's roads
It’s heartening to see some Michigan lawmakers taking a stab at a long-term solution for the state’s road funding shortfall.Continued ...
- Letters to the Editor: 04/23/2014