Why not import clean energy using wires instead of railroad cars?
"Please send me your clean, affordable, reliable and fact-based solutions to where we will get electricity 24 hours a day, seven days a week and 365 days a year," was a recent request by one of our region's electricity providers.
Michigan has a long history of meeting its power supply needs from generation built within our state and we import 37 million tons of coal each year in order to do this. Even the new 25 x 25 renewable energy ballot proposal requires a 100 percent "in-state" mandate in order to achieve its 25 percent renewable energy goals. The least-cost energy solution for Michigan ratepayers, however, is more likely to be a combination of in-state and regional generation, according to the Midwest Independent System Operator (MISO), which operates our 11-state power grid.
Why not import clean energy, using wires instead of railroad cars?
It makes sense to source new wind projects in Michigan. DTE Energy's 140-megawatt Huron Wind Project is forecast to operate at a 47 percent capacity factor and generate electricity at a cost of about 5.5 cents per kilowatt-hour. It's good business for them to invest $500 million in wind projects in Huron and Sanilac counties. If we are willing to think outside the box, however, we can open a much larger field of clean, affordable and reliable energy solutions.
MISO's Midwest Transmission Expansion Plan, MTEP-11, proposes upgrades to the transmission infrastructure that would allow for low-cost energy imports to Michigan by relieving constraints that limit the flow of economic energy from the western MISO regions. Some large wind power projects in these regions offer electricity costs as low as 3 or 4 cents per kWh, which could benefit Michigan ratepayers.
All power plants are intermittent. Intermittent wind power can be accommodated using: 1) advanced wind forecasting techniques; 2) normally available operating reserves ("backup"), of 12 percent to 18 percent of total system demand, which are used during power plant outages; 3) energy storage systems like the Ludington plant; 4) demand-side management (e.g. our business periodically cuts demand by as much as 3 megawatts), and; 5) energy balancing between geographic regions via the MISO transmission infrastructure. This is how the power grid operator keeps the lights on.
In a recent Michigan Public Service Commission electric utility case the cost to back up intermittent renewable energy in 2012 was shown to be less than 0.5 cents per kwh using capacity available from the power grid.
Compare the cost of new large wind power, including electricity back-up electricity from a new coal plant, reported by the MPSC to cost 13.3 cents per kWh, not including its back-up costs.
High energy costs are like a tax. As a large power user I would like to see more wind energy in our power supply portfolio because it is clean, affordable, reliable and has zero fuel cost. It will also help inoculate Michigan ratepayers against inevitable fossil fuel cost increases to come.
About the author: Jim MacInnes worked as a power engineer for the company that designed the Ludington Pumped Storage facility. He has held a professional engineer's license and membership in the electrical engineer's professional association for over 30 years. He is chair of the Michigan Utility Consumer Participation board, whose job it is to fund qualified interveners in electric and gas utility rate cases before the MPSC on behalf of residential ratepayers. He is also the CEO of Crystal Mountain resort.
About the forum: The forum is a periodic column of opinion written by Record-Eagle readers in their areas of interest or expertise. Submissions of 500 words or less may be made by e-mailing email@example.com. Please include biographical information and a photo.
Why not import clean energy using wires instead of railroad cars?
Editorial: Housing Commission overdoes cuts in reaction to sequester
It’s not often a local government faces criticism for being too conservative with public money or going too far in limiting spending.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 03/12/2014
An impressive group; Opposed to Air Walk; Best-kept secret.Continued ...
Another View: Real-world changes for admission test
In the realm of education, the Scholastic Aptitude Test has something of a make-or-break reputation.Continued ...
Editor's note: Opinion poll
To our readers: Doonesbury creator Garry Trudeau will no longer produce the daily cartoon that has been a fixture on the Record-Eagle’s Opinion page for many years.Continued ...
Editorial: Plan to power Northport with sun, wind worth try
It’s one thing to debate the merits of renewable energy like wind and solar power. But it’s rare to see the concept put to a real-world test like the one planned for Northport.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 03/11/2014
Allow us to be proud.Continued ...
Another View: Industry support of e-cigs deserves skepticism
The sellers of addictive substances will try to convince you otherwise, but they’re in the business of getting people hooked on their products.Continued ...
- Monday, March 10, 2014
To child care providers across the region who have scrambled to take in children for the day when area school districts have closed because of bad winter weather.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 03/10/2014
Not a good example; Expect minimal help.Continued ...
- Sunday, March 9, 2014
Editorial: Years of effort, commitment created Sleeping Bear plan
Back in 2002 the National Park Service decided that about half of the Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore needed additional protection against development, vehicle traffic and commercial activity.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 03/09/2014
Protect our minds; Recognize the effort.Continued ...
Forum: A better formula for school reform
Over the past generation, school reform has been predicated on the notion that accountability to student performance on standardized tests would drive improvement.Continued ...
Jack Lessenberry: Why government doesn't work anymore
Want two glaring examples of why many liberals - as well as conservatives - think government doesn’t work anymore?Continued ...
- Saturday, March 8, 2014
Letters to the Editor: 03/08/2014
Assumptions improvable.Continued ...
Another View: Russia’s preferred isolation
Russia’s occupation of the Crimean Peninsula is part of a futile effort to reverse history.Continued ...
Another View: Tax reform proposal sounds good, but may lack support
If there’s one thing that Democrats and Republicans in Washington agree on, it’s that America needs a simpler tax code.Continued ...
Fact Check: Americans in 'deep poverty' hits record
Republicans in the U.S. House of Representatives recently released a study that critiqued the current mix of federal anti-poverty programs and suggested a new way forward.Continued ...
Fact Check: Hagel says Congress responsible for defense cuts
President Barack Obama (has) released his proposed budget for fiscal year 2015 ... One point of contention is that the budget he proposed will reduce the army to its smallest size since 1940.Continued ...
- Friday, March 7, 2014
Editorial: Beach testing grant exposes state's lack of commitment
The issue: GT Band to fund beach testing program for 2014. Our view: Grant points up state's failure to act.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 03/07/2014
Where was Snyder?; Time to fight back.Continued ...
Another View: 'Giant' ancient virus raises concerns
In the 1951 science fiction classic “The Thing from Another World,” a spacecraft crashes in the arctic. A group of humans investigates and discovers an alien buried in ice. Once thawed, the alien poses a threat to the humans, who eventually destroy it.Continued ...
- Thursday, March 6, 2014
Editorial: County board must codify what counts as per diem
The issue: GT board can’t agree on per diem payments. Our view: It’s another case of a flawed policy.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 03/06/2014
Reasons to be happy.Continued ...
Forum: Return to local control
What happens within a prison population when prisoners convicted of violent crimes are mixed in with inmates incarcerated for non-violent crimes?Continued ...
Phil Power: Dingell's professionalism will be missed
Maybe the best way to understand how John Dingell survived and prospered over what will be a record-breaking 59 years in the U.S. House of Representatives is to go back to the summer of 2002.Continued ...
- Editorial: Housing Commission overdoes cuts in reaction to sequester