LANSING — It has been a tough year so far for some judges.
In Ottawa County, District Judge Kenneth Post faces ethics charges alleging he failed to follow the law, behaved inappropriately toward a defense lawyer and "trivialized" the seriousness of a criminal case.
Post acknowledged in legal papers that his courtroom comments to the lawyer were "sarcastic and possibly demeaning," that he failed to act courteously and "may have made an error of law," but denied any serious violations of the state's Code of Judicial Conduct.
In Wayne County, Circuit Judge Deborah Adams faces ethics charges in which the Judicial Tenure Commission accused her of making misrepresentations under oath and forgery in her own divorce case.
She denies any misconduct, and her hearing has concluded, with a decision expected soon, said commission Executive Director Paul Fischer. Post's hearing is scheduled for Dec. 17-18.
If the charges are upheld, they could face censure, suspension or removal from office.
The commission is an investigatory and prosecutorial arm of the Michigan Supreme Court with oversight responsibility for 1,259 state court judges.
Meanwhile this year, the Supreme Court has bounced two judges from the bench.
It removed Jackson District Judge James Justin for unethical and illegal behavior, including fixing tickets for his wife, his staff and himself.
Justin's "multitudinous acts of proved misconduct sketch a common theme," the Supreme Court said. "He failed to follow the law, apparently believing that it simply did not apply to him."
He now faces felony charges of misconduct in office, a crime that carries a potential maximum sentence of five years in prison and a $10,000 fine.
The Supreme Court also removed Inkster District Judge Sylvia James for financial, administrative and professional misconduct, including allegations of nepotism and misuse of court funds.
James is running in the Nov. 6 election to regain her seat now held by an interim appointee, Judge Sabrina Johnson.
Such high-profile cases are the exception, not the rule, because most grievances against judges are thrown out or dealt with in private.
The tenure Commission has logged a steady litany of complaints — technically requests for investigation — in recent years.
Last year, it received 546 requests for investigation, down from 638 in 2010, according to its annual report. Litigants, including inmates, filed 90 percent of them.
"A substantial percentage alleged legal error not involving misconduct or expressed dissatisfaction with a judge's discretionary handling of judicial duties," the report said. Other complaints involved people outside the commission's authority, such as former judges and federal judges.
Last year the commission issued 9 private letters of caution, admonition or explanation — all of them confidential.
Even though details of the letters are private, including the names of the judges and courts involved, the commission's latest annual report provides evidence of the wide array of verified misconduct.
For example, judges were privately chastised for:
n failing to decide a child custody and visitation case for more than two years, a delay that "likely exacerbated the process of reuniting the parent and child."
n refusing to let a litigant consult with his lawyer and "badgered the litigant with questions."
n calling a litigant angry and bitter, and a "baby." The judge also said, "Please get out of my courtroom; I — I don't want to look at you."
n making inappropriate statements, including suggesting that litigant have her teeth "fixed," and asking if she was "a little self-conscious" about them. The commission also found "somewhat disparaging" the judge's comments about a litigant getting his "brains knocked out in a bar" and "feeding" alcohol to a brain injury.
n failing to disclose that the judge was the landlord for a lawyer who regularly appeared in the same court.
n mishandling the appointment of a lawyer for a criminal defendant. "The commission noted that the judge's lack of knowledge regarding the matter was somewhat remarkable, and cause for concern," the report said.
n refusing to allow a police officer to retain or photocopy evidence in a felony case and ordering the evidence returned to the defendant.
n repeatedly misrepresenting evidence, not following the law and considering out-of-court information in parental rights cases.
n pressuring a candidate to withdrawing from a judicial campaign by phoning the candidate's law firm partners. "The judge's colleague and friend was the only other person in the judicial race."
n filing for a homestead exemption for property taxes on two residences although the law allows the exemption for only one primary residence.
n using court letterhead to solicit charitable donations while running for re-election. "The personal solicitation of funds for a charitable cause created the appearance that the organization was being used as a campaign vehicle for free publicity," the commission said.
Fischer, the commission executive director, said he hopes its work "has an impact, not only on judges but on the public as well," including raising awareness that the state has an organization that can take action if judges misbehave.
Eric Freedman directs and writes for Michigan State University's Capital News Service.
Ottawa, Wayne county judges face charges
LANSING — It has been a tough year so far for some judges.
NMC board to address OMA allegations
Northwestern Michigan College trustees on Monday will discuss allegations they violated state open meetings laws. But they might do so behind closed doors.Continued ...
Local officials: Email no way to conduct public business
Local government officials expressed surprise and concern over a newspaper report that Northwestern Michigan College trustees may have violated state law when they used email and other non-public means to deliberate and decide a proposal to videotape their meetings.Continued ...
Mancelona's story similar, unique
This Antrim County community’s story mirrors those of many small towns. Industry boomed. Franchised stores shot up, mom-and-pops struggled to compete. Industry left, commerce sufferedContinued ...
Dems drum up opposition for Leelanau seats
Republicans dominated the Leelanau County ballot for years, but they’ll have some company this year.Continued ...
Betsie River, Crystal Lake to be part of watershed management plan
It’s all about groundwater. So said Ed Hoogterp. He’s the former president of the Crystal Lake and Watershed Association who spearheads work on a watershed management plan for the area that runs east of Interlochen to the Frankfort lighthouse.Continued ...
- Saturday, April 19, 2014
Plane returns to Cherry Capital
A Delta Airlines flight returned to Cherry Capital Airport minutes after takeoff because of a problem with the plane’s landing gear.Continued ...
Becoming the new voice of summer
Ernie Harwell was the voice of Detroit Tigers baseball. He was the voice of spring, the voice of summer, the voice of the outdoor barbecue with a transistor radio, the voice of the little kid listening to baseball after bedtime and the voice of theContinued ...
Theory and neighbors' sentiment collide on rezoning
TRAVERSE CITY -- City commissioners face a choice between following their housing ideology or bowing to residents who call a proposed development of four mid-priced houses both ludicrous and dangerous. Architect John Kerridge proposes to construct foContinued ...
Blair Elementary has new leader
Blair Elementary has new leader TRAVERSE CITY -- Blair Elementary School has a new leader in place for next school year. Traverse City Area Public Schools administrators selected Kirsten Jones-Morgan to replace Sharon Dionne, who will retire July 1.Continued ...
Leelanau Peninsula Chamber to get new website
Leelanau Chamber to get new website TRAVERSE CITY -- It's time for a makeover for the Leelanau Peninsula Chamber of Commerce's website. Leelanau County Commissioners voted to allocate up to $10,000 in 2 percent grant money earmarked for economic devContinued ...
19th century skull returned to Band for ceremony
TRAVERSE CITY -- One Leelanau County family heirloom will no longer be passed down to the next generation. Sheriff Mike Borkovich said a family who did not want to be named gave his office a human skull that had been in the family for years. An elderContinued ...
- Friday, April 18, 2014
Flight returns to Cherry Capital
TRAVERSE CITY — A Delta Airlines flight returned to Cherry Capital Airport minutes after takeoff because of a problem with the plane's landing gear.Continued ...
Attorney files for reorganization
TRAVERSE CITY -- A prominent Traverse City attorney's law practice remains open after he sought bankruptcy protection amid a lengthy and potentially costly legal battle with a former client. Clarence Gomery, of Gomery Law Offices, said his April 2 baContinued ...
Kalkaska fire destroys rentals
TRAVERSE CITY -- Fire tore through an apartment building in the south end of the Village of Kalkaska. Kalkaska County Sheriff David Israel said he didn't think anyone was seriously injured or killed in the Thursday afternoon blaze, but the entire buiContinued ...
Trojans capture Up North Invite
From staff reports TRAVERSE CITY -- Traverse City Central won seven of eight flights Thursday to capture the Up North Invitational. The Trojans finished with 23 points, Petoskey 15, Cadillac 9 and Traverse City West 1. Central's winners included: PaiContinued ...
Kalkaska County Board Chair to resign
TRAVERSE CITY -- Kalkaska County's longest-serving commissioner will resign at the end of the month. Debra Kimball, who represents Kalkaska Township, but not the village, stepped down from her position as board chair at a meeting Tuesday night. She mContinued ...
Kalkaska honors Dewey, Sieting
KALKASKA -- Rodger Dewey started his insurance agency in a Mancelona train car in 1971. It was the only office space left in town. Dewey and his family have since moved the business to a building in Kalkaska, guided it through the dawn of computers,Continued ...
Clearing the Record 04/18/2014
Because of incorrect information provided to the Record-Eagle, James Vernon Meadows' age was incorrectly reported in a Tuesday story about a multiple-injury vehicle crash in Antrim County. Antrim Sheriff Daniel Bean on Thursday said Meadows is 35.Continued ...
Caldwell sentenced in woman's death
TRAVERSE CITY -- A Traverse City man who said he accidentally shot his girlfriend to death in a failed suicide attempt will serve a sentence of about 11.5 to 19 years, the maximum sentence. Robert Lee-Allen Caldwell, 33, plead guilty to involuntary mContinued ...
Titans split twinbill at Grand Haven
From staff reports GRAND HAVEN -- Max Ludka collected two hits, scored three runs and drove in one as Traverse City West beat Grand Haven 15-9 in the first of two games. Jake Dean earned the win in relief. Wes Talbot and Keegan Kenny each drove in twContinued ...
Acme decision: Lovett or leave it
TRAVERSE CITY -- Lyle Lovett concert posters decorate bulletin boards throughout Traverse City, but that may be as close as the country music artist and actor gets to town, if promoters can't swing a zoning permit. Lovett and His Large Band are schedContinued ...
GT board picks Gourdie-Fraser as engineer firm for county
TRAVERSE CITY -- Grand Traverse County's Board of Public Works selected the local firm that designed and built the county's long-troubled septage treatment plant to serve as its engineer of record for the next three years. Gourdie-Fraser Inc. beat ouContinued ...
Second NMC stabbing suspect pleads guilty
BY SARAH ELMS email@example.com Second NMC stabbing suspect pleads guiltyContinued ...
4 Non Blondes to reunite for 1 night at L.A. event
NEW YORK (AP) -- What's up with 4 Non Blondes? How about a one-night-only reunion? The '90s rock band will perform May 10 at "An Evening With Women" to benefit the L.A. Gay & Lesbian Center. Linda Perry, the band's former lead singer and hit songwriContinued ...
- Thursday, April 17, 2014
Emails show NMC leaders made decisions outside public meetings
Northwestern Michigan College’s elected officials debated in a flurry of emails whether to televise their monthly board meetings, a behind-the-scenes decision-making process that altered some trustees’ public opposition and occurred outside the public eye.Continued ...
- NMC board to address OMA allegations