TRAVERSE CITY — BY ART BUKOWSKI
Multiple stab wounds in Carly Lewis' body were caused by police as they probed for her body in a large sand pile, a defense attorney contends.
The murder trial of Robert Jensen Schwander, 18, began today in 13th Circuit Court in Traverse City. Schwander is charged with an open count of murder in Carly's June 2 death.
Assistant Grand Traverse County Prosecutor Noelle Moeggenberg in her opening statements said Schwander repeatedly stabbed Carly, 16, with a scissor blade inside a Beitner Road storage hut that served as Schwander's temporary home.
But defense attorney Craig Elhart said Schwander instead strangled her to death during a heated argument, and wasn't responsible for a series of stab wounds later described by a forensic pathologist.
"These stab wounds were not done by Jensen Schwander," he said, referencing Schwander by the name he most often uses. "They were done by the Michigan State Police."
Workers from the state police crime lab were called to search a sand pile used by Traverse City's street crews after interviewing Schwander, who police said disclosed the location of her body. The sand pile is a stone's throw from the hut where police believe the murder occurred.
A forensic pathologist said Carly died of a deep stab wound to her chest, one of 10 puncture wounds discovered on her body during an autopsy. State police crews used a long metal probe to search the pile, Elhart said, and that probe caused the wounds.
Elhart will attempt to prove Schwander didn't intend to kill Carly, and thus could be convicted of manslaughter. A jury could convict him of first-degree murder — which requires premeditation — second-degree murder, or manslaughter.
Moeggenberg argued that Schwander, who lived with Carly's family after being kicked out of his own home, planned to kill Carly because he blamed her for his forced departure from the Lewis home.
Carly's body was found wrapped in trash bags, and Elhart told a jury he'll attempt to prove that holes in the trash bag correspond to stab wounds on her body.
"Is it logical for any one of us to sit here and believe that she was put in a bag and then stabbed?" Elhart said. "That is completely illogical. And each one of these wounds corresponds in large part to a defect in the bag that was caused by the Michigan State probe."
After opening arguments, the jury heard testimony from Susie Lewis and Mitchell Lewis, Carly's mother and brother. Both testified about a tense relationship between Lewis and Schwander, who was invited to live in the home by Mitchell Lewis.
"Some days they seemed buddy-buddy, other days they seemed like mortal enemies," Mitchell Lewis said.
Susie Lewis said Carly and Schwander appeared to bond at times — possibly over drug use — but never appeared overly close.
"They just really didn't get along," she said. "He told me and others that he didn't really like her."
Carly planned to meet Schwander the afternoon of June 2 at the Glen's market on Eighth Street. Police believe the teens headed to a storage hut, where they got in an argument.
Police said Schwander told them that Carly assaulted him at the hut, so he punched her in the face, and she fell and hit her head on concrete flooring. Elhart today said she continued to struggle and Schwander ultimately strangled her.
The trial will continue Thursday and is expected to last through the end of next week.
TRAVERSE CITY — BY ART BUKOWSKI
Snyder talks taxes, Medicaid
Gov. Rick Snyder thinks the state of Michigan finally got it right on attempts to reform the personal property tax on business.Continued ...
Painting with sand
The Dennos Museum Center of Northwestern Michigan College is ringing with noise this week as Tibetan Buddhist monks construct a Mandala sand painting in the center of the museum.Continued ...
Center renovations underway
Planned Parenthood of West and Northern Michigan’s local health center is getting a face-lift thanks to money raised through the organization’s Standing Tall capital campaign.Continued ...
Sketch leads to attempted robbery suspect
A forensic sketch of a suspect in an attempted pharmacy robbery in Elk Rapids helped village police nab a potential culprit.Continued ...
Clearing the Record: 04/16/2014
Because of a photographer’s error, Matthew Failor and William Kalajian were incorrectly listed as qualifying for the National Geographic Bee in the Monday’s edition of the Record-Eagle.Continued ...
- Tuesday, April 15, 2014
Rivers recede, residents watch sky for rain
Area rivers and streams began to recede with the recent sunshine, but riverfront property owners worry about a forecast that calls for a chance of more snow and rain through the weekend.Continued ...
TBAISD adopts new teacher evaluation model
Educators across the Traverse Bay Area Intermediate School District soon will be evaluated under new guidelines.Continued ...
Bid for teacher evaluation system open
The Traverse Bay Area Intermediate School District seeks sealed bids for its new educator evaluation system.Continued ...
Suttons Bay High School teacher resigns after kiss with student
A Suttons Bay High School teacher had an “inappropriate,” but not illegal, relationship with a student in the senior class, the school district’s top administrator said.Continued ...
Custodian's sentence upheld
The son of a former Traverse City school board president this month lost his final appeal to trim an eight- to 15-year prison sentence for his conviction on charges of criminal sexual conduct with a 13-year-old student.Continued ...
Renowned planner to discuss Eighth Street
Robert Gibbs, a national leader in new sustainable town planning and commercial market research, will lead a discussion on remaking what one city official described as Traverse City’s tired, under-performing corridors into economic powerhouses of life and energy.Continued ...
Five injured in Antrim County crash
Authorities are investigating a two-vehicle crash in rural Antrim County that sent five Mancelona residents to the hospital.Continued ...
- Monday, April 14, 2014
High water, low temps
Rivers are rising and the temperature is falling as the start-and-stop transition from winter to spring continues.Continued ...
Suttons Bay teacher resigns after accusations
A Suttons Bay High School teacher resigned after accusations arose that she carried on an "inappropriate" relationship with a male student who is in the senior class.Continued ...
Teens make top 10 in geo bee
The whole world is fair territory in the National Geographic Bee. The annual competition is an educational program of the National Geographic Society designed to encourage the teaching and study of geography.Continued ...
Task force takes long look at teen pregnancy
Pregnant teens are an "invisible" population. "They may drop out of school, they may not have access to transportation and they're often marginalized," said Marjorie Rich, the Women's Resource Center Doula Client Advocate.Continued ...
Grand Traverse Teen Pregnancy at a glance
Grand Traverse teen pregnancy at a glance:Continued ...
Leelanau sheriff’s department adds four-legged officer
Steve Morgan knows first-hand the value of a good police dog. So one of his first moves as Leelanau County’s new undersheriff in 2013 was to suggest that the department acquire its first K-9.Continued ...
- Sunday, April 13, 2014
Report details 'bogus deal'
A woman suspected in a fatal shooting in Long Lake Township told authorities last year she received a beating from unknown assailants after she tried to set up a fake $30,000 drug deal, according to a newly released police report.Continued ...
Board goes paperless for savings, privacy
Grand Traverse County road commissioners referenced saving paper, improving communication and cutting back on wasted staff time before they unanimously voted to purchase iPads for board members’ use.Continued ...
The Franklin prepares to sizzle
The business partners stood on the second floor of the new building at Cass and Front streets as a chilly rain cascaded to the streetscape below.Continued ...
Drones flying despite ban; industry wants rules
State and university officials as well as entrepreneurs in Michigan await results of a federal appeal that will affect how a commercial drone industry develops in the state and across the country.Continued ...
TCAPS schools can apply for 3-D printer
Conceptualize a product. Design it on a computer. Print it on a machine.Continued ...
Kids can read to furry friend at Suttons Bay library
Children in Suttons Bay will have a new buddy to read to at the Suttons Bay Bingham District Library this month.Continued ...
Trail work scheduled in National Lakeshore
Transportation officials hope that by summer families will be able to bike from northern Empire to Glen Arbor on a path that would weave through Sleeping Bear National Lakshore.Continued ...
- Snyder talks taxes, Medicaid