Traverse City Record-Eagle

Latest News - Mobile

May 19, 2013

Townships settle 12-year-old lawsuit with Cherryland

TRAVERSE CITY — Three holdout local townships finally settled a drawn-out tax dispute with Cherryland Electric Cooperative prior to a full hearing before the Michigan Supreme Court.

The dispute centered around excess personal property taxes paid by rural electric cooperatives from 1999 through 2001. The property taxes due were computed using a flawed form issued by the Michigan Tax Commission, and Cherryland wanted a refund from Garfield, East Bay, and Blair townships worth about $125,000.

The state Supreme Court dismissed the case Friday.

Cherryland attorney Norman Shinkle said the settlement with Blair, East Bay, and Garfield townships was similar to agreements reached with 50 or 60 other townships prior to a 2012 Michigan Court of Appeals decision.

"These were the last three," Shinkle said. "All of the other cases were settled prior to the appeal; these were settled post."

Blair Township Supervisor Pat Pahl said Cherryland offered to settle for 90 percent of the refund owed them, but final details are still being worked out.

The Michigan Tax Tribunal ruled in favor of rural cooperatives in 2008, and determined the over-payment caused by the faulty form was an error of fact, which under state law entitled Cherryland to a three-year refund.

The townships argued the state tax commission changed its position on what should be considered when calculating the property tax on electrical transmission lines, making it an issue of law not subject to the refund. The appeals court sided with Cherryland, and the three townships appealed to the state Supreme Court.

"Originally, we asked for an (immediate) reversal and were hopeful the court would grant that right off the bat," said Thomas Grier, attorney for the townships.

The court hears oral arguments in March but denied the townships' request and instead scheduled the question for a full hearing, more oral arguments and more briefs.

"We were faced with a lot of extra costs and from a cost-benefit analysis the parties didn't want to pursue it," Grier said.

Text Only

Twitter Updates
Follow us on twitter
Associated Press Video
Bill Murray Continues To Be Just Bill Murray By Eating Some Free Bill Murray Ice Cream Deja vu: Another NYPD officer choke-holding a suspect Hillary Clinton Blamed Bill's Affair With Monica Lewinsky On Abuse He Suffered As A Child 'Fifty Shades of Grey': Watch the Super Sexy First Trailer Now! Reports: Ravens RB Ray Rice Suspended For 1st 2 Games Of The Season Chapter Two: Becoming a first-time director Air Algerie plane with 119 on board missing over Mali Diamond Stone, Malik Newman, Josh Jackson and others showcase talent Free Arturo - The World's Saddest Polar Bear A Look Back at Batman On Film Through The Years LeBron James -- Dropped $2k On Cupcake Apology ... Proceeds To Benefit Charity Snoop Dogg Says He Smoked Weed at the White House Raw: Fight Breaks Out in Ukraine Parliament Chris Pratt Interrupts Interview To French Braid Intern's Hair Shirtless Super Mario Balotelli Dances While Ironing - @TheBuzzeronFOX Whoa! Watch "Housewives" Star Do the Unthinkable LeBron apologizes to neighbors with cupcakes Justin Bieber In Calvin Klein Underwear Shoot Samsung Pre-Trolls The IPhone 6 With New Ad Jimmy Kimmel Introduces His Baby Girl