BY ANNE STANTON firstname.lastname@example.org
Traverse City Record-Eagle
---- — MANCELONA — An emerald green class ring lost 44 years ago made its way to its rightful and incredibly grateful owner in an improbable reunion.
“It’s amazing this could happen after 44 years,” said Nelson Hoogerhyde of Alba. “It was crazy. You couldn’t make up this kind of stuff.”
Hoogerhyde, 75, found the ring in the fall of 1969 when he was washing his GTO hot rod at a self-serve car wash off Garfield Avenue in Traverse City. He returned it on May 12 to Stephen “Mike” Willsey of Lake Ann at an emotional meeting at a Mancelona diner.
Willsey said he quickly realized he lost the ring, but by the time he returned to the car wash, it was already gone. He thinks Hoogerhyde must have found it within an hour after he dropped it.
Willsey was particularly heartbroken because he knew the sacrifice his family made to buy the $150 ring, a small fortune back then. He helped pay for a good share of the ring by working 50-cent-an-hour jobs, but knew better than to ask his family to chip in for a replacement.
Hoogerhyde said he noticed a glint in a drain grate in the floor, and found the ring bundled up in gum wrappers. He kept the ring inside a box of Muncie transmission synchro rings, which luckily contained a preservative to keep the synchro rings from rusting. It also kept the class ring in perfect condition.
Hoogerhyde eventually bought a 1968 Chevelle convertible and forgot to take the rings out of the glove box. Fortunately, the new owner of the GTO returned the synchro ring box back to Hoogerhyde. Years later, Hoogerhyde put the class ring in a box of his Vietnam military metals and dog tags.
Every year around graduation time, Hoogerhyde thought about the owner of the class ring, and periodically placed ads in the Record-Eagle. Once he tried contacting Traverse City Central High School, but with no luck.
“Every year, it bothered me a little bit,” he said.
This past year, his granddaughter graduated as the valedictorian of Mancelona High School, and he became determined to find the ring’s owner. He took out a magnifying glass and discovered the inscribed year was 1971, not 1972, as he had mistakenly thought when he first looked at the ring in 1969. It had the initials of SMH.
Hoogerhyde went on the Internet and found a contact person for an upcoming 40th high school reunion.
“I fired off an email,” Hoogerhyde said.
Nancy Nash, a Traverse City Central High School alumna, got the message and started the whole ball rolling, he said.
“A couple of days later, through her contacts, she found out who it was,” he said.
The two men met up at Shirley’s Diner in Mancelona and shared their life stories over coffee and pie.
“What interested me most was Mr. Hoogerhyde doing whatever he could to get it back to the owner’s hand,” Willsey said.
Hoogerhyde said he was glad to do it.
“It’s strange how things work out,” he said. “It’s strange I would have kept this ring, moved it three times, still had it, he was still around, still wanted it, and we reconnected.”