Why not import clean energy using wires instead of railroad cars?
"Please send me your clean, affordable, reliable and fact-based solutions to where we will get electricity 24 hours a day, seven days a week and 365 days a year," was a recent request by one of our region's electricity providers.
Michigan has a long history of meeting its power supply needs from generation built within our state and we import 37 million tons of coal each year in order to do this. Even the new 25 x 25 renewable energy ballot proposal requires a 100 percent "in-state" mandate in order to achieve its 25 percent renewable energy goals. The least-cost energy solution for Michigan ratepayers, however, is more likely to be a combination of in-state and regional generation, according to the Midwest Independent System Operator (MISO), which operates our 11-state power grid.
Why not import clean energy, using wires instead of railroad cars?
It makes sense to source new wind projects in Michigan. DTE Energy's 140-megawatt Huron Wind Project is forecast to operate at a 47 percent capacity factor and generate electricity at a cost of about 5.5 cents per kilowatt-hour. It's good business for them to invest $500 million in wind projects in Huron and Sanilac counties. If we are willing to think outside the box, however, we can open a much larger field of clean, affordable and reliable energy solutions.
MISO's Midwest Transmission Expansion Plan, MTEP-11, proposes upgrades to the transmission infrastructure that would allow for low-cost energy imports to Michigan by relieving constraints that limit the flow of economic energy from the western MISO regions. Some large wind power projects in these regions offer electricity costs as low as 3 or 4 cents per kWh, which could benefit Michigan ratepayers.
All power plants are intermittent. Intermittent wind power can be accommodated using: 1) advanced wind forecasting techniques; 2) normally available operating reserves ("backup"), of 12 percent to 18 percent of total system demand, which are used during power plant outages; 3) energy storage systems like the Ludington plant; 4) demand-side management (e.g. our business periodically cuts demand by as much as 3 megawatts), and; 5) energy balancing between geographic regions via the MISO transmission infrastructure. This is how the power grid operator keeps the lights on.
In a recent Michigan Public Service Commission electric utility case the cost to back up intermittent renewable energy in 2012 was shown to be less than 0.5 cents per kwh using capacity available from the power grid.
Compare the cost of new large wind power, including electricity back-up electricity from a new coal plant, reported by the MPSC to cost 13.3 cents per kWh, not including its back-up costs.
High energy costs are like a tax. As a large power user I would like to see more wind energy in our power supply portfolio because it is clean, affordable, reliable and has zero fuel cost. It will also help inoculate Michigan ratepayers against inevitable fossil fuel cost increases to come.
About the author: Jim MacInnes worked as a power engineer for the company that designed the Ludington Pumped Storage facility. He has held a professional engineer's license and membership in the electrical engineer's professional association for over 30 years. He is chair of the Michigan Utility Consumer Participation board, whose job it is to fund qualified interveners in electric and gas utility rate cases before the MPSC on behalf of residential ratepayers. He is also the CEO of Crystal Mountain resort.
About the forum: The forum is a periodic column of opinion written by Record-Eagle readers in their areas of interest or expertise. Submissions of 500 words or less may be made by e-mailing firstname.lastname@example.org. Please include biographical information and a photo.
Why not import clean energy using wires instead of railroad cars?
High School Sports Scoreboard: 03/07/2014
A roundup of scores from today's boys district basketball tournament games:Continued ...
Benzonia woman accused of prescription fraud
A Benzonia woman faces a felony charge after authorities said she fraudulently obtained hundreds of prescription pills.Continued ...
Panthers roar in regional final
Tim Reznich is hoping Frankfort can have a reunion with Nicole Marshall. And history says the Panthers may very well do that.Continued ...
Dispatch: Smart911 worth the price
An online service that gives Grand Traverse County 911 responders potentially vital information about callers cost taxpayers almost $19 per call in its first half-year of operation.Continued ...
TC native joins Team Blake on TV's 'The Voice'
Ryan Whyte Maloney finally can spill the beans: he’s a bona fide contestant on “The Voice.”Continued ...
Editorial: Beach testing grant exposes state's lack of commitment
The issue: GT Band to fund beach testing program for 2014. Our view: Grant points up state's failure to act.Continued ...
Passengers wrongly told TC airport was ‘closed’
Len Price and his family just wanted to get home. The Traverse City resident, 72, his wife, Linda, and son Logan were headed home from a Montana skiing vacation March 1 when weather caused long delays to their United Airlines flight.Continued ...
Pastor sues former church over contract
A controversial pastor’s public schism with his former church moved into the legal realm.Continued ...
OTP revives 'Sound of Music' after 20 years
Kathy Verstraete unearthed some familiar artifacts while she packed her mother’s home two years ago.Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 03/07/2014
Where was Snyder?; Time to fight back.Continued ...
Building Permits: 03/07/2014
Building permits issued in Grand Traverse County:Continued ...
Frankfort coach elected president of coach association
A pair of girls basketball victories and a regional championship weren’t the only things Tim Reznich won this week.Continued ...
McBain captures Class C regional title
McBain rebounded from a poor shooting performance in the first half to overtake Beaverton and secure a 61-44 decision Thursday in a Class C girls regional championship game.Continued ...
And the Oscar (contest) goes to ...
Holly MacAulay did her homework and it showed when she her Oscar contest entry landed among four with perfect scores.Continued ...
The Record: 03/07/2014
Assumed names issued in Grand Traverse County:Continued ...
Downtown boat ramp hits bump
A plan to redesign a Boardman River boat launch in Traverse City is temporarily grounded because some local environmentalists weren’t consulted about changes.Continued ...
Back to school — for parents
Traverse City area parents will have a chance to go back to kindergarten at Grand Traverse Academy on March 13.Continued ...
Former TC student teacher returns as singer-songwriter
Josh Rose found musical inspiration in some unusual places growing up on a sheep farm in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula.Continued ...
Weekend in Brief: 03/07/2014
"Pure A Cappella" showcase; Mel Larimer concert series continues; and more.Continued ...
NMC's Birmley Road observatory open to public tonight
Two realms of science fascinate all types of people, regardless of age, said Jerry Dobek, a science and math instructor at Northwestern Michigan College.Continued ...
Night Life Calendar: 03/07/2014
What's going on after dark:Continued ...
Sports in Brief: 03/07/2014
Coach Mike Krzyzewski is out of the hospital and at practice with No. 4 Duke after feeling light-headed during a loss at Wake Forest. (Plus more)Continued ...
Movie Capsules: 03/07/2014
New this week — 300: Rise of an Empire — Greek general Themistokles leads the charge against invading Persian forces led by mortal-turned-god Xerxes and Artemisia, vengeful commander of the Persian navy.Continued ...
Community in Brief: 03/07/2014
Mexican Dinner Party benefit; Titan Student Choreographed Dance Concert; Grand Traverse Humanists meet; A Matter of Honor (AMOH) event; and more.Continued ...
- Poll: Does state set aside enough money to test beaches?
- High School Sports Scoreboard: 03/07/2014