Why not import clean energy using wires instead of railroad cars?
"Please send me your clean, affordable, reliable and fact-based solutions to where we will get electricity 24 hours a day, seven days a week and 365 days a year," was a recent request by one of our region's electricity providers.
Michigan has a long history of meeting its power supply needs from generation built within our state and we import 37 million tons of coal each year in order to do this. Even the new 25 x 25 renewable energy ballot proposal requires a 100 percent "in-state" mandate in order to achieve its 25 percent renewable energy goals. The least-cost energy solution for Michigan ratepayers, however, is more likely to be a combination of in-state and regional generation, according to the Midwest Independent System Operator (MISO), which operates our 11-state power grid.
Why not import clean energy, using wires instead of railroad cars?
It makes sense to source new wind projects in Michigan. DTE Energy's 140-megawatt Huron Wind Project is forecast to operate at a 47 percent capacity factor and generate electricity at a cost of about 5.5 cents per kilowatt-hour. It's good business for them to invest $500 million in wind projects in Huron and Sanilac counties. If we are willing to think outside the box, however, we can open a much larger field of clean, affordable and reliable energy solutions.
MISO's Midwest Transmission Expansion Plan, MTEP-11, proposes upgrades to the transmission infrastructure that would allow for low-cost energy imports to Michigan by relieving constraints that limit the flow of economic energy from the western MISO regions. Some large wind power projects in these regions offer electricity costs as low as 3 or 4 cents per kWh, which could benefit Michigan ratepayers.
All power plants are intermittent. Intermittent wind power can be accommodated using: 1) advanced wind forecasting techniques; 2) normally available operating reserves ("backup"), of 12 percent to 18 percent of total system demand, which are used during power plant outages; 3) energy storage systems like the Ludington plant; 4) demand-side management (e.g. our business periodically cuts demand by as much as 3 megawatts), and; 5) energy balancing between geographic regions via the MISO transmission infrastructure. This is how the power grid operator keeps the lights on.
In a recent Michigan Public Service Commission electric utility case the cost to back up intermittent renewable energy in 2012 was shown to be less than 0.5 cents per kwh using capacity available from the power grid.
Compare the cost of new large wind power, including electricity back-up electricity from a new coal plant, reported by the MPSC to cost 13.3 cents per kWh, not including its back-up costs.
High energy costs are like a tax. As a large power user I would like to see more wind energy in our power supply portfolio because it is clean, affordable, reliable and has zero fuel cost. It will also help inoculate Michigan ratepayers against inevitable fossil fuel cost increases to come.
About the author: Jim MacInnes worked as a power engineer for the company that designed the Ludington Pumped Storage facility. He has held a professional engineer's license and membership in the electrical engineer's professional association for over 30 years. He is chair of the Michigan Utility Consumer Participation board, whose job it is to fund qualified interveners in electric and gas utility rate cases before the MPSC on behalf of residential ratepayers. He is also the CEO of Crystal Mountain resort.
About the forum: The forum is a periodic column of opinion written by Record-Eagle readers in their areas of interest or expertise. Submissions of 500 words or less may be made by e-mailing email@example.com. Please include biographical information and a photo.
Why not import clean energy using wires instead of railroad cars?
- Poll: Will city determine who made bad decisions on splash pad?
Education Newsmakers: 08/02/2014
The following area students were named to the Dean’s List at Grand Valley State University, Allendale, for winter 2014:Continued ...
Blood Drive Calendar: 08/02/2014
Area Blood Drives: American Red Cross — Kalkaska, 12:30-5:15 p.m., Aug. 4, Kaliseum Recreation Complex, 1900 Fairgrounds. (Plus more)Continued ...
Music In The Movies: Moore, Morello talk music, politics
Michael Moore gave Rage Against The Machine one director’s note during the filming of the music video for “Sleep Now in the Fire” on New York City’s Wall Street — “Whatever happens, don’t stop playing.”Continued ...
Bay-to-bay trail plan at Sleeping Bear Dunes
National Lakeshore and National Park Service officials are working with the Friends of Sleeping Bear Dunes to develop a trail plan for hikers and paddlers along the Lake Michigan shoreline, and they want to hear from the public.Continued ...
Blood drive to benefit crisis center
A local blood drive is set to help more than patients awaiting blood transfusions.Continued ...
Challenger questions incumbent
The Republican primary race for Grand Traverse County’s 4th District commission seat pits a challenger who claimed his opponent isn’t a true fiscal conservative against an incumbent who’s running on his experience and knowledge of the county’s history.Continued ...
Film Festival Outtakes: 08/02/2014
Traverse City Film Festival fans still have a good shot at seeing the sold-out shows. Sid VanSlyke, venue manager at the City Opera House, said the theater sold 105 stand-by tickets to a movie showing at last year’s festival.Continued ...
Film Festival Schedule: 08/02/2014
What's happening Saturday at the Traverse City Film Festival:Continued ...
Adapted in TC: Remembering a TC Film Fest friend
I met Oscar-nominated filmmaker Paul Mazursky five years ago at the Traverse City Film Festival.Continued ...
Body & Soul in Brief: 08/02/2014
Walk against cancer; Book study group; Boats on the Boardwalk show. (Plus more)Continued ...
Letters to the Editor: 08/02/2014
Does the right thing; Amend zero-tolerance; Purchase is a bailout.Continued ...
Going to the fair
Scott Gray strolled along a line of recreation vehicles stretched as far as the eye could see when he spotted Nancy Ellis laboring to tie lights onto an awning of the family camper. Gray stopped to help.Continued ...
Ag Forum: What's your missing link?
In business and in life, when we have problems, we often look for silver bullets, the easy answer, the dramatic solution, the big score.Continued ...
Short's partner appointed to state committee
Gov. Rick Snyder appointed Scott Newman-Bale, a founding partner in Short's Brewing Company, to the Michigan Economic Development Corp. Executive Committee.Continued ...
Saskatoons at Tom's Food Markets
A Leelanau County farm that grows unique Saskatoon berries will display how to cook with the fruit at Tom's Food Markets.Continued ...
TC sidewalk ordinance again up for debate
City commissioners don't plan to let a sidewalk ordinance fall through the cracks.Continued ...
Candidates hope varied experience will speak to voters
Two Republican candidates hope careers that span multiple sectors will help them win votes on primary election day.Continued ...
Mysterious pro-Schmidt robocall linked to Clinch Park Marina
Local caller IDs lit up with the digits 922-4903 as residents fielded yet another automated campaign message ahead of the Aug. 5 primary election.Continued ...
Authorities: Cedar man violated protection order
A Cedar man's drunken, motorized jaunt in front of a woman's home detoured into Leelanau County's jail after authorities said it violated a personal protection order she filed against him.Continued ...
Businessman delivers pizza to boaters — on Sea-Doo
Long Lake Grocery owner Nick Ferrugia contemplated how to boost pizza sales to boaters on nearby Long Lake one sleepless night when the idea arrived like a wave.Continued ...
Motorcycle backfire kindles Kalkaska house fire
A motorcycle backfire sparked a fire that spread through a Kalkaska man's garage and then into his house.Continued ...
City commissioners to pick pier designers
A committee chose a design and engineering group that boasts public engagement skills over another group with a reputation for marine engineering acumen to craft a fishing pier at the mouth of the Boardman River.Continued ...
TC gets a movie makeover
Designing a great storefront window is all about telling a story, and downtown businesses had a tale to tell during the Traverse City Film Festival.Continued ...
Buddhist Lama to visit Omena
"Can they hear me or not?" Many of Marie Elena Gaspari's friends wonder about this and so much more as they care for older relatives or get close to losing them, she said.Continued ...