What caused the Brown Bridge Dam failure?
As a semi-retired engineer who has specialized in dam and hydroelectric projects, I have been reading with much interest the articles about the recent failure of the Brown Bridge Dam.
The aerial photo that appeared in the Record-Eagle a couple of weeks ago tells a very compelling story about the failure. As someone who has designed, built and operated dams over the past 45 years, and has spent a good deal of time studying dam failures, I can attest that the driving of sheet piling through an earthen embankment is a very questionable practice.
The vibration resulting from the pile-driving operation loosens the soil on both sides of the piling wall and thus creates a path of low resistance to the flow of water. If the soil is not dense and well compacted, water will begin to seep through the soil along the smooth surface of the steel piling and create a path for an increasing amount of flow.
Once the flow of water increases to the point where it begins to flow out of the downstream face of the embankment, the erosion process begins. After the flow of water has developed along this path, the rate of erosion can increase dramatically and a failure can occur in a matter of minutes or hours, as was the case with the Brown Bridge Dam.
The proximity of a concrete retaining wall, if in fact that's what it was, would be of very little help since once started, the water would erode under the bottom of the wall and the wall would shift or fail allowing more water to pass.
Although the state and others say they will never absolutely know for sure what caused the failure, I would expect investigations will quite conclusively determine the failure scenario. Over the past 10 years or more there have been a number of dams removed in United States and much experience has been gained in the process. There are much safer ways to drain a reservoir.
About the author: Frank Christie of Onekama is a registered engineer and a member of the Association of State Dam Safety Officials. He has 45 years of experience in the design, construction and operation of dams and small hydroelectric facilities. He is currently managing the operations of four such facilities in central Michigan located on the Tittabawassee River.
About the forum: The forum is a periodic column of opinion written by Record-Eagle readers in their areas of interest or expertise. Submissions of 500 words or less may be made by emailing email@example.com. Please include biographical information and a photo.
What caused the Brown Bridge Dam failure?
Forum: A better formula for school reform
Over the past generation, school reform has been predicated on the notion that accountability to student performance on standardized tests would drive improvement.Continued ...
Forum: Return to local control
What happens within a prison population when prisoners convicted of violent crimes are mixed in with inmates incarcerated for non-violent crimes?Continued ...
Forum: $180M removed from mental health programs
Gov. Snyder’s upbeat message on the 2015 budget left out an important fact: that in a time of state revenue surplus, about $180 million in state general funds are being removed from community mental health programs in Michigan.Continued ...
Forum: Time we all celebrated Darwin Day
In case you missed, it, Happy Darwin Day.Continued ...
Forum: Tranquility jeopardized by growth
“I thought as I sat there of the ancient admonition 'Be still and know that I am God' and knew that without stillness there can be no knowing, without divorcement from outside influences man cannot know what spirit means.”Continued ...
- Friday, February 21, 2014
Forum: Creating Dann’s House
StonesHouse, Inc., a local nonprofit committed to helping communities develop recovery residences, was recently awarded a $35,000 grant from the Michigan Department of Community Health to open Dann’s House.Continued ...
- Thursday, February 20, 2014
Forum: Energy efficiency pays off in many ways
These sub-zero temperatures have been challenging for all of us.Continued ...
- Sunday, February 16, 2014
Forum: Traverse City has a dilemma
Traverse City has a dilemma. Recent city commissions and administrations have been so financially prudent that a surplus of your tax dollars have collected in our savings accounts.Continued ...
- Friday, February 14, 2014
Forum: Autistic Peer Mentoring program
Recently my wife, myself, and another parent were invited to speak with 24 students who are involved in the Autistic Peer Mentoring program at Traverse City West Senior High.Continued ...
- Sunday, February 9, 2014
Forum: Safe Harbor's building proposal
The Grand Traverse region needs to approach homelessness by furthering the plan to end it.Continued ...
- Friday, February 7, 2014
Forum: TCL&P, TCSaves and what it means to you
Recently the Traverse City Light & Power Board and staff completed a six-month strategic planning process which identified many areas of focus for the utility, one of which is energy efficiency.Continued ...
- Wednesday, February 5, 2014
Forum: Bring fairness to ticket resale market
In Michigan, it is perfectly legal to resell an event ticket above face value on websites that are selected as “authorized resellers.” However, if a fan has a friend or neighbor willing to buy their ticket above face value, that person-to-person transaction is illegal under current state law.Continued ...
- Thursday, January 30, 2014
Forum: Issue of abortion is a moral one
I don’t believe the abortion issue is only a Catholic issue or a Protestant issue or a Jewish issue or a political issue, or a social issue. Rather, I see this as a moral issue.Continued ...
- Wednesday, January 29, 2014
Forum: We need to expand presence for the arts
In the past week, there have been several references to the financial and operational difficulties at the History Center.Continued ...
- Tuesday, January 21, 2014
Forum: We once again need a prophet
Is Phil Robertson of the television show “Duck Dynsaty” a prophet? The question might seem absurd, as Phil never claimed to hear from the Lord and never levied a warning.Continued ...
- Friday, January 17, 2014
Forum: Rogers Observatory an interesting gem
Traverse City is blessed with interesting little gems, from wonderful restaurants to pocket parks, and favorite spots on the Boardman River or TART Trail.Continued ...
- Thursday, January 16, 2014
Forum: Do more to keep invaders out
Zebra mussels have become a household name because of the significant environmental and economic damage they have caused across the Great Lakes region.Continued ...
- Wednesday, January 15, 2014
Forum: Easy to CARE about neighbors in need
Each winter, especially as the weather turns frigid, Michigan residents rightly ask how to help our neighbors in need.Continued ...
- Sunday, January 12, 2014
Forum: Give the gift of giving in the New Year
You may have recently seen announcements of grant awards to benefit a wide variety of organizations, programs, and projects in communities throughout our region.Continued ...
- Sunday, January 5, 2014
Forum: Fracturing facts present different picture
The Dec. 15 forum from the Northern Michigan Environmental Action Council stating that hydraulic fracturing is such a threat that it should be banned “immediately, everywhere,” was purely an attempt to cause alarm and anxiety.Continued ...
- Sunday, December 15, 2013
Forum: Fracking, more harm than good
The Northern Michigan Environmental Action Council has concluded that horizontal hydraulic fracturing, commonly known as fracking, should be banned.Continued ...
- Sunday, December 8, 2013
Forum: Contrasting care for mentally disabled
Recently the Northern Lakes Community Mental Health Authority celebrated its 10th anniversary and the 50th anniversary of the Community Mental Health Act.Continued ...
- Thursday, November 28, 2013
Forum: Honoring loved ones during holidays
The holidays are approaching fast. As beautiful and as spiritual the holidays can be, when someone you love has died it can be one of the most difficult times of the year.Continued ...
- Wednesday, November 27, 2013
Forum: Structuring collaborative partnerships
In this world of constant change, requirements for dealing with the contradictions that arise from today’s environment should encourage leadership in the public sector to think differently when structuring collaborative partnerships.Continued ...
- Tuesday, November 26, 2013
Forum: Unprecedented storms more of the norm
Hurricane Sandy and Typhoon Haiyan were unprecedented storms in weather history, but neither was really a surprise.Continued ...
- Forum: A better formula for school reform